When it comes to choosing the right tires for your vehicle, the options can be overwhelming.
That’s why I decided to dive into the BFGoodrich vs Toyo debate.
In this post, we’ll explore the rich histories of these two brands, examine their performance in dry, wet, and snowy conditions, analyze their mileage warranties and average lifespan, compare prices, and weigh the pros and cons.
By the end, we’ll determine which brand reigns supreme.
Let’s get started!
BFGoodrich vs Toyo – Comparison Table
| BFGoodrich | Toyo | |
| Country of Origin | United States | Japan |
| Year Founded | 1870 | 1945 |
| Made In | Tuscaloosa, AL, Woodburn, IN, or Opelika, AL in the US | Japan, Malaysia or the United States |
| Parent | Compagnie Générale des Établissements Michelin SCA (France) | Toyo Tire Corporation (Japan) |
About the Brands
1. BFGoodrich
BFGoodrich, a renowned tire brand, has a rich history that dates back to its founding in 1870 in the United States.
Originally known as Goodrich, the company began producing rubber products and expanded into tires in the late 19th century.
They quickly gained prominence for their quality and innovative designs.
In 1988, Goodrich became a subsidiary of Uniroyal-Goodrich, which later merged with the French tire giant Michelin in 1990.
As a result, BFGoodrich became part of the Compagnie Générale des Établissements Michelin, solidifying its global presence.
BFGoodrich has always been at the forefront of tire technology, pioneering advancements such as all-terrain tires and radial tires.
Their tires have been trusted by drivers on various terrains, from racetracks to challenging off-road environments.
With a legacy spanning over a century, BFGoodrich continues to deliver high-performance tires, catering to diverse vehicles and driving needs.
Their strong association with Michelin ensures that the brand remains synonymous with quality, durability, and innovation in the tire industry.
Mostly Known for Manufacturing Tires For:
- Passenger cars
- SUVs (Sport Utility Vehicles)
- Trucks
- Off-road vehicles
- Commercial vehicles
2. Toyo
Toyo Tire Corporation, a renowned Japanese brand, has a rich history dating back to its establishment in 1945.
Founded in Japan, Toyo has grown to become a leading global tire manufacturer.
Operating under the parent company Toyo Tire Corporation, they have built a reputation for providing high-quality tires for a diverse range of vehicles.
Over the years, Toyo has developed advanced tire technologies and innovative designs to meet the evolving needs of drivers around the world.
With a strong commitment to performance, safety, and durability, Toyo has become a trusted choice for drivers seeking reliable tires.
With its Japanese heritage and global presence, Toyo continues to push the boundaries of tire engineering, ensuring exceptional performance and driving experiences for customers worldwide.
Mostly Known for Manufacturing Tires For:
- Passenger cars
- Light trucks
- SUVs (Sport Utility Vehicles)
- High-performance cars
- Luxury cars
- Family cars
- Trucks
- Buses
Differences
1. Dry Performance
I’m going to compare the performance of two summer tires as they are the ideal type in dry weather.
I’m taking a look at the BFGoodrich g-Force Sport COMP-2 vs the Toyo Proxes R1R.
In my evaluation, the BFGoodrich g-Force Sport COMP-2 tire demonstrates outstanding dry performance, earning a rating of 4.7 out of 5.
It excels in dry grip, traction, responsiveness, cornering, and handling.
Its superior dry traction, surpassing its competition, further emphasizes its strength.
On the other hand, the Toyo Proxes R1R tire exhibits impressive overall performance, receiving a rating of 4.4 out of 5.
It offers exceptional dry traction, handling, and maintains block stiffness during aggressive braking.
While the BFGoodrich g-Force Sport COMP-2 takes the lead, both tires perform admirably in dry conditions, resulting in a tie for dry performance.
2. Wet Performance
For the wet performance, I’ll be comparing the BFGoodrich Advantage T/A Sport vs the Toyo Proxes Sport A/S.
Based on my research and personal rating, the BFGoodrich Advantage T/A Sport tire receives a wet performance rating of 3.8 out of 5.
While it offers adequate wet performance, reviews indicate potential issues with traction, stopping distances, and acceleration.
On the other hand, the Toyo Proxes Sport A/S tire receives a higher rating of 4.6 out of 5 for wet performance.
It excels in wet braking and delivers reliable performance on wet roads.
Therefore, the Toyo Proxes Sport A/S emerges as the better choice for wet performance.
3. Snow Performance
We all know that you need dedicated winter tires if you’re going to be driving on harsh winter conditions.
That’s why I’ll be comparing the snow performance of two specialized winter tires – BFGoodrich Winter T/A KSI vs Toyo Observe GSi-6.
Based on my research and personal assessment, I would rate the snow performance of both the BFGoodrich Winter T/A KSI and the Toyo Observe GSi-6 tires as 4.5 out of 5.
These tires showcase impressive features such as high sipe density, saw-toothed groove edges, a new compound (in the case of BFGoodrich), Microbit studless technology, serrated stability ribs, high-grip silica compound, and aggressive tread design.
Both options excel in providing reliable traction on snowy surfaces and are designed to handle extreme winter conditions.
Therefore, it is a tie between these two excellent choices for snow performance.
4. Mileage Warranty and Tread Life
| BFGoodrich | Toyo | |
| Treadwear Warranty | up to 75,000 miles tread life warranty | up to 65,000 miles tread life warranty |
| Average Tread Life | BFGoodrich tires are expected to last mostly between the 50,000 to 60,000 miles mark. | The actual lifespan of Toyo tires can range from 40,000 to 60,000 miles. |
Based on my research, BFGoodrich tires offer a higher mileage warranty compared to Toyo tires.
BFGoodrich provides up to 75,000 miles of tread life warranty, while Toyo offers up to 65,000 miles.
However, the average lifespan of BFGoodrich tires typically falls between 50,000 to 60,000 miles, whereas Toyo tires can last from 40,000 to 60,000 miles.
So, while BFGoodrich offers a longer warranty, both brands have similar average lifespans.
5. Prices
In this section, I’ll be taking a look at the price ranges of both tire brands – BFGoodrich vs Toyo.
I’ll be using one of the biggest tire and wheel retailers in the US for this comparison – Discount Tire.
Here is a comprehensive table that showcases each brand has to offer:
| BFGoodrich | Toyo | |
| Average Price Range (Discount Tire) | $112 to $747 /ea | $82 to $1,030 /ea |
| Cheapest Tire (Discount Tire) | Advantage Control goes from $112 – $238 /ea | Extensa HP II goes from $82 – $253 /ea |
| Most Expensive Tire (Discount Tire) | Mud Terrain T/A KM3 goes from $217 – $747 /ea | Open Country M/T goes from $297 – $1,030 /ea |
6. Pros and Cons
BFGoodrich
| Pros | Cons |
| ✔ Competitively priced with above-average mileage on the tread-warranties | ❌ They lack tire diversity compared to other brands, and the brand’s passenger options are limited in sizes |
| ✔ Highly focused and specialized in all-season and off-road tires | |
| ✔ Great option for daily commutes and road trips |
Toyo
| Pros | Cons |
| ✔ Generally considered to be of high quality, offering durability and reliability | ❌ Some of their tires can get expensive |
| ✔ Toyo offers a wide range of tire options for different types of vehicles and driving needs, including all-season, summer, and winter tires | |
| ✔ Excellent traction and handling in rugged terrain |
7. Popular Tires
Here are some notable tires from BFGoodrich:
- All-Terrain T/A KO2
- Mud-Terrain T/A KM3
- Advantage T/A Sport LT
Some of Toyo’s best tires are shown below:
- Proxes Sport
- Open Country A/T III
- Extensa A/S II
Which Is the Better Brand Overall?
After considering the key takeaways and comparing the BFGoodrich and Toyo tire brands, I have come to a conclusion.
In terms of dry performance, it’s a tie as both brands offer exceptional grip and handling.
However, Toyo takes the lead in wet performance with better traction and braking.
When it comes to snow performance, both brands excel equally.
While BFGoodrich offers a longer mileage warranty, the average lifespan is similar for both brands.
Considering all factors, I declare Toyo as the better overall pick.
