When it comes to choosing the right tires for your vehicle, the competition between Goodyear and Pirelli is fierce.
In this post, I’ll delve deep into the Goodyear vs Pirelli debate, comparing their histories, dry, wet, and snow performance, mileage warranties, average lifespan, prices, and uncovering the pros and cons of each brand.
By the end, we’ll determine which tire brand reigns supreme.
So, fasten your seatbelts and let’s dive into this gripping battle of rubber and tread.
Goodyear vs Pirelli – Comparison Table
| Goodyear | Pirelli | |
| Country of Origin | United States | Italy |
| Year Founded | 1898 | 1872 |
| Made In | mostly in Akron, United States, but the company also has factories in Venezuela, India, Turkey, and Malaysia | Rome, GA, Hanford, CA, Madison, TN, or internationally in Brazil, Mexico, Romania, or Venezuela |
| Parent | The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company (USA) | Pirelli & C. S.p.A. (Italy) |
About the Brands
1. Goodyear
The Goodyear brand, founded in 1898 in the United States, is a renowned tire manufacturer and a subsidiary of The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company.
It has a rich history that spans over a century.
Goodyear has consistently displayed a commitment to innovation, quality, and performance.
Throughout the years, they have developed groundbreaking technologies and patented tire designs that revolutionized the industry.
The brand’s success can be attributed to its dedication to providing reliable tires for various vehicles, including cars, trucks, motorcycles, and aircraft.
Goodyear’s products have garnered a reputation for their durability, traction, and superior handling.
Over time, the company has expanded its global footprint, establishing a strong presence in numerous countries.
Today, Goodyear remains a trusted and respected name in the tire industry, continuously pushing boundaries to meet the evolving needs of consumers worldwide.
Mostly Known for Manufacturing Tires For:
- Passenger cars
- SUVs (Sport Utility Vehicles)
- Light trucks
- Commercial trucks
- Buses
- Motorcycles
- Racing cars
- Farm equipment
- Heavy earth-moving machinery
- Aircraft
- Bicycles
2. Pirelli
Pirelli, an iconic tire brand, was founded in Italy in 1872.
Originally named “G.B. Pirelli & C.”, the company started as a small rubber goods factory in Milan.
With a vision for innovation, Pirelli quickly expanded its operations and began producing bicycle tires.
In 1901, Pirelli introduced its first automobile tire, marking a significant milestone in its history.
Over the years, Pirelli continued to grow and diversify its product range, becoming a renowned global leader in the tire industry.
The brand’s commitment to cutting-edge technology and high-performance tires earned it a reputation for excellence.
Pirelli tires were even chosen as the official tires for the Formula One World Championship, showcasing their unparalleled performance on the racetrack.
Today, Pirelli is a subsidiary of Pirelli & C. S.p.A., headquartered in Italy.
The company remains dedicated to pushing the boundaries of tire technology, constantly innovating to meet the evolving needs of drivers worldwide.
With a rich heritage spanning over 150 years, Pirelli continues to be synonymous with quality, performance, and Italian craftsmanship.
Mostly Known for Manufacturing Tires For:
- Passenger cars
- SUVs (Sport Utility Vehicles)
- Light trucks
Differences
1. Dry Performance
I’m going to compare the performance of two summer tires as they are the ideal type in dry weather.
I’m taking a look at the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 vs the Pirelli P Zero.
In my opinion, as the one giving the dry performance rating from 1 to 5, the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 edges out the Pirelli P Zero with a rating of 4.5 compared to 4.3.
The Goodyear tire has received highly positive ratings for its short dry braking distance, good handling speed, and remarkable dry traction.
While the Pirelli P Zero also performs well with precise handling, excellent dry grip, and a focus on sporty performance, the Goodyear tire slightly surpasses it in terms of overall dry performance.
Therefore, the Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3 is the better choice for dry performance.
2. Wet Performance
For the wet performance, I’ll be comparing the Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady vs the Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus.
After thoroughly researching and analyzing the wet performance of the Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady and the Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus tires, I would rate the former at 4.3 and the latter at 4.5 on a scale of 1 to 5.
Both tires exhibit impressive features and positive feedback regarding their wet traction, handling, and control.
It is challenging to declare a clear winner as both tires offer similar levels of wet performance.
Therefore, I would consider it a tie between the Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady and the Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus in terms of wet performance.
3. Snow Performance
We all know that you need dedicated winter tires if you’re going to be driving on harsh winter conditions.
That’s why I’ll be comparing the snow performance of two specialized winter tires – Goodyear Ultra Grip Ice WRT vs Pirelli Winter Sottozero 3.
Based on my research, as the one providing the snow performance rating from 1 to 5, I would rate the Goodyear Ultra Grip Ice WRT tire at 4.4 and the Pirelli Winter Sottozero 3 tire at 4.6.
Both tires offer reliable snow performance, with the Goodyear tire featuring Winter Reactive Technology and a directional tread design for enhanced traction, while the Pirelli tire boasts excellent handling and grip on snowy roads.
However, due to the slightly higher rating, the Pirelli Winter Sottozero 3 tire takes the lead in terms of snow performance.
4. Mileage Warranty and Tread Life
| Goodyear | Pirelli | |
| Treadwear Warranty | up to 80,000 miles tread life warranty | up to 65,000 miles tread life warranty |
| Average Tread Life | Goodyear tires are expected to last anywhere between 30,000 to 65,000 miles on average. | Pirelli offers a range of tire models, with most lasting between 45,000 to 65,000 miles. |
Based on my research, Goodyear tires come with a treadwear warranty of up to 80,000 miles, while Pirelli tires offer a warranty of up to 65,000 miles.
On average, Goodyear tires last between 30,000 and 65,000 miles, whereas Pirelli tires have a lifespan ranging from 45,000 to 65,000 miles.
These numbers indicate that Goodyear tires tend to have a slightly higher mileage warranty, but both brands offer comparable average lifespans for their tires.
5. Prices
In this section, I’ll be taking a look at the price ranges of both tire brands – Goodyear vs Pirelli.
I’ll be using one of the biggest tire and wheel retailers in the US for this comparison – Discount Tire.
Here is a comprehensive table that showcases each brand has to offer:
| Goodyear | Pirelli | |
| Average Price Range (Discount Tire) | $75 to $1,027 /ea | $85 to $1,665 /ea |
| Cheapest Tire (Discount Tire) | Eagle RS-A goes from $75 – $299 /ea | Cinturato Winter goes from $85 – $145 /ea |
| Most Expensive Tire (Discount Tire) | Eagle NCT5 goes from $317 – $1,027 /ea | P Zero Corsa PZC4 goes from $339 – $1,665 /ea |
6. Pros and Cons
Goodyear
| Pros | Cons |
| ✔ Wide range of tire options for different types of vehicles | ❌ Goodyear tires can be more expensive compared to other brands |
| ✔ Goodyear tires are known for their high quality and durability | |
| ✔ Long history of producing specialized tires for racing |
Pirelli
| Pros | Cons |
| ✔ Pirelli is the exclusive tire supplier for Formula 1 | ❌ Some of their tires can get crazy expensive |
| ✔ Pirelli have an overall decent lifespan of their tires | |
| ✔ Innovative technology, such as the EverGrip technology |
7. Popular Tires
Here are some notable tires from Goodyear:
- Eagle F1 Asymmetric 3
- Assurance WeatherReady
- Wrangler All-Terrain Adventure with Kevlar
Some of Pirelli’s best tires are shown below:
- P Zero
- Cinturato P7 All Season Plus
- Scorpion Verde All Season Plus
Which Is the Better Brand Overall?
Based on the comparison between Goodyear and Pirelli tires, it is evident that both brands offer commendable performance in various aspects.
The Goodyear tire outperforms the Pirelli tire in terms of dry performance, while both are equally impressive in wet conditions.
When it comes to snow performance, the Pirelli tire slightly takes the lead.
In terms of mileage warranty and average lifespan, both brands offer similar performance.
Considering all these factors, I declare the Pirelli tire as the better pick overall due to its slightly superior snow performance.