Arizonian Tires vs. Goodyear (In-Depth Comparison)

Whether to choose the Arizonian or Goodyear tire brand is a decision you must base on several important factors.

Quality, price, warranty, etc., all play an essential role when you put Arizonian tires vs. Goodyear.

The main difference between Arizonian and Goodyear tires is that they target different types of customers. Arizonian is aimed at budget-conscious buyers, while Goodyear tries to offer the best product for top dollar.

But these are not the only differences between these two brands, as we will show you in the rest of this comparison article.

There are more details that you should know before making up your mind about these brands.

So, let’s check out everything you need to know about these two tire brands.

Arizonian Tires vs. Goodyear Comparison

Before going into the details of each property, we have compared these brands, so let’s check them out quickly.

In our experience, these are the things that most buyers compare when choosing between different tire brands.

PerformanceAbove averageTop
DurabilityAbove averageTop
Warranty60K miles0-80K miles


When it comes to comparing prices, we take a look at the price tags of the cheapest and most expensive tires and what you would have to pay for the pleasure of owning them.

But disregarding all other factors that decide their value and whether they are worth the price.

Arizonian tires cost in the range between $80 and $145, a price range that can be described only as low.

And from it, you must conclude that these tires are marketed for drivers that do not want to spend too much on tires. Budget-conscious buyers, in other words.

But, we will see later are they worth their price or not.

Goodyear, on the other hand, has a much wider price range for its products, spanning between $75 and $866.

But the slightly lower starting price can be deceiving, as the average price of their tire is closer to $250.

When comparable tires are compared, Goodyear tires are $50 to $120 more expensive.


Comparing the performance of products from tire brands can be a complex thing. There are many:

  • different products
  • different cars
  • driving styles
  • levels of experience
  • road conditions

The same tire can perform very differently when any of these factors are changed.

Fortunately, we have the help of the NHTSA standardized Uniform Tire Quality Grading (UTQG) system.

The first UTQG rating we will look at is traction, which is measured as the friction force of the tire when completely locked.

Arizonian tires are graded A for traction, the second-highest rating and the same as the majority of Goodyear products.

But the other competitor has some tires that are graded AA, which are the high-performance summer tires for which Arizonian doesn’t have a comparable model.

The second rating is the ability of the tire to dissipate heat at a sustained speed. When driving, tires heat up, and each has a point at which it is hot enough for its performance to deteriorate.

Arizonian models are rated B, placing this maximum speed between 100mph and 115mph.

Goodyear tires are rated the same or better, grade A or, in other words, for above 115mph.


The third UTQG rating, which tells you how much you can expect a tire to last you is the treadwear rating.

Because many different factors impact the rate of tread wear, it is measured in comparison to a reference tire which is rated 100.

If some tire is rated 400, it can be expected to last four times longer under the same driving condition compared to the reference tire.

Arizonian has only one tire model on the market at the moment, and it is rated 600 for treadwear.

This means that it will last some six times longer than the reference tire used for testing.

Such rating is decently better than most passenger car tires, which are mostly in the 300 to 500 range.

Goodyear produces a wide range of differently specialized tires. Some UHP tires sacrifice durability for performance and have a treadwear rating as low as 100.

But Goodyear products are engineered to last more than their competitors, and most of their products are rated in the range between 550 and 650, with some models going all the way to 800.

Related: Ironman Tires vs. Michelin (In-Depth Comparison)


When it comes to comparing the variety of products between Arizonian and Goodyear, it is hard not to notice the stark difference between these two brands.

Arizonian is a brand owned by Cooper Tires; Rubber Company and marketed solely through the Discount Tire stores.

The fact which should lead you to presume that there is a limited number of models.

And you would be right, as they have only one tire model, the Silver Edition all-seasons tire, which comes in 18 different dimensions.

For many years, Goodyear has been a company that grabs the largest tire market share of all manufacturers. And they do it by having an extremely large product range.

If a vehicle rolls on tires, there is a Goodyear product for it. And many carmakers have Goodyear-produced OEM tires.

In numbers, that is more than 60 models in almost 700 dimension variants.

Related: Yokohama vs. Toyo Tires (In-Depth Comparison)


When it comes to warranty policy, what you should be interested in is the warranty miles coverage.

The sole Arizonian tire model is covered by a 60 thousand miles warranty policy, which will provide you with more than enough insurance for any manufacturing defects.

Because its silica-infused tread compound and 11/32″ tread depth will provide you with many more miles of lifespan than that.

Because of the wide range of products, Goodyear offers a wide range of warranty miles, ranging between zero miles and all the way up to 80 thousand miles.

Outside the UHP tires, which are built to perform, Goodyear products are engineered to last longer than competitors. And for many products warranty is between 60 and 70 thousand miles.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Arizonian Tires

Arizonian is the brand of affordable tires, and they are priced lower than practically all other tire brands in the market.

But their advantage over similarly priced brands is the quality, performance, and longevity.

The biggest disadvantage of Arizonian tires, which may prevent you from choosing them, is the very low availability of different models.

There is only one currently on the market. And it is sold only through the Discount Tire chain.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Goodyear Tires

Goodyear is the largest tire maker in the US. Its name is the synonym for many motorsports, such as NASCAR. And such reputation was built on the quality of their products.

They are ubiquitous on the market. And they promise both longevity and performance. The wide range of products assures that you can find a model for any vehicle.

But, top quality demands top dollar. Goodyear tires are generally among the most expensive tires on the market.

Related: Cooper vs. Pathfinder Tires (In-Depth Comparison)


Arizonian vs. Goodyear is the comparison of two widely different tire brands.

The first is budget-friendly and offers a very limited number of products, while the other is arguably the largest tire manufacturer in the States.

Which one is better comes down to what you need?

If you are looking for an affordable tire for certain vehicles that will safely get you from point A to point B, Arizonian could be a better choice.

But, if you are looking for the best product that will allow you to squeeze out the last bit of performance of your car on the road or track, and the price is not a concern, there is only Goodyear as an option.

Related: Achilles Tires vs. Michelin (In-Depth Comparison)